NY's Abortion Clinic Buffer Zones Intact
New York's attorney general told police Thursday that legal buffer zones around abortion clinics are intact in 22 of the state's counties despite the recent U.S. Supreme Court ruling striking down the 35-foot protest-free zone outside clinics in Massachusetts
In an open letter to law enforcement agencies, Attorney General Eric Schneiderman said his office won't let anti-abortion activists use "a narrowly targeted" court decision to create confusion. The court ruling affirmed that states can protect their interest in ensuring access to reproductive health services, he said.
New York City law sets a 15-foot buffer zone in front of clinics. A federal court in Buffalo issued an injunction in 2005 requiring protesters to abide by a 15-foot zone at clinics in 17 counties in western New York.
"Not only do New York state's clinic protection laws remain completely in place, I am committed to working with our partners in law enforcement to ensure they are fully enforced," Schneiderman said. He has also sent out investigators to ensure clinic access, he said.
The letter followed a protest last week outside the Planned Parenthood clinic in Rochester, where one demonstrator crossed a faded line on the sidewalk believing the Supreme Court decision applied everywhere, said Mary Jost. She is director of the Focus Pregnancy Help Center nearby and a longtime anti-abortion protester. Police were called, an officer talked with the woman and said she had to move back. That also prompted Rochester police to query the attorney general's office and Jost to consult her own lawyer, who advised staying beyond the line that was subsequently painted bright orange, she said.
"We might take it to court in time," Jost said. Up to 15 protesters are outside the clinic on surgery days and they try to persuade young women to come instead to her center two doors down with offers of free services including help with adoption, she said.
When he ran for attorney general four years ago, Schneiderman was endorsed by Planned Parenthood Advocates of New York. He was cheered at an Albany campaign event where he promised to aggressively defend their rights to birth control. He noted that at 17, he worked at a Washington clinic that provided abortions.